Section 18
Chapter 18 — Neil Gordon Solves His Own Problem explained simply
Kilmeny of the Orchard by L. M. Montgomery
Original excerpt
Excerpt preview
It was the first time he had spoken since Eric and Kilmeny had rushed in, hand in hand, like two children intoxicated with joy and wonder, and gasped out their story together to him and Janet.
Read full original text in reading mode
Public-domain original
"It is a miracle!" said Thomas Gordon in an awed tone.
It was the first time he had spoken since Eric and Kilmeny had rushed
in, hand in hand, like two children intoxicated with joy and wonder, and
gasped out their story together to him and Janet.
"Oh, no, it is very wonderful, but it is not a miracle," said Eric.
"David told me it might happen. I had no hope that it would. He could
explain it all to you if he were here."
Thomas Gordon shook his head. "I doubt if he could, Master—he, or
any one else. It is near enough to a miracle for me. Let us thank God
reverently and humbly that he has seen fit to remove his curse from
the innocent. Your doctors may explain it as they like, lad, but I’m
thinking they won’t get much nearer to it than that. It is awesome, that
is what it is. Janet, woman, I feel as if I were in a dream. Can Kilmeny
really speak?"
"Indeed I can, Uncle," said Kilmeny, with a rapturous glance at Eric.
"Oh, I don’t know how it came to me—I felt that I MUST speak—and I
did. And it is so easy now—it seems to me as if I could always have
done it."
She spoke naturally and easily. The only difficulty which she seemed to
experience was in the proper modulation of her voice. Occasionally she
pitched it too high—again, too low. But it was evident that she would
soon acquire perfect control of it. It was a beautiful voice—very clear
and soft and musical.
"Oh, I am so glad that the first word I said was your name, dearest,"
she murmured to Eric.
"What about Neil?" asked Thomas Gordon gravely, rousing himself with an
effort from his abstraction of wonder. "What are we to do with him when
he returns? In one way this is a sad business."
Eric had almost forgotten about Neil in his overwhelming amazement and
joy. The realization of his escape from sudden and violent death had not
yet had any opportunity to take possession of his thoughts.
"We must forgive him, Mr. Gordon. I know how I should feel towards a man
who took Kilmeny from me. It was an evil impulse to which he gave way in
his suffering—and think of the good which has resulted from it."
"That is true, Master, but it does not alter the terrible fact that
the boy had murder in his heart,—that he would have killed you. An
over-ruling Providence has saved him from the actual commission of the
crime and brought good out of evil; but he is guilty in thought and
purpose. And we have cared for him and instructed him as our own—with
all his faults we have loved him! It is a hard thing, and I do not see
what we are to do. We cannot act as if nothing had happened. We can
never trust him again."
But Neil Gordon solved the problem himself. When Eric returned that
night he found old Robert Williamson in the pantry regaling himself with
a lunch of bread and cheese after a trip to the station. Timothy sat on
the dresser in black velvet state and gravely addressed himself to the
disposal of various tid-bits that came his way.
"Good night, Master. Glad to see you’re looking more like yourself.
I told the wife it was only a lover’s quarrel most like. She’s been
worrying about you; but she didn’t like to ask you what was the trouble.
She ain’t one of them unfortunate folks who can’t be happy athout
they’re everlasting poking their noses into other people’s business.
But what kind of a rumpus was kicked up at the Gordon place, to-night,
Master?"
Eric looked amazed. What could Robert Williamson have heard so soon?
"What do you mean?" he asked.
"Why, us folks at the station knew there must have been a to-do of some
kind when Neil Gordon went off on the harvest excursion the way he did."
"Neil gone! On the harvest excursion!" exclaimed Eric.
"Yes, sir. You know this was the night the excursion train left. They
cross on the boat to-night—special trip. There was a dozen or so
fellows from hereabouts went. We was all standing around chatting when
Lincoln Frame drove up full speed and Neil jumped out of his rig. Just
bolted into the office, got his ticket and out again, and on to the
train without a word to any one, and as black looking as the Old Scratch
himself. We was all too surprised to speak till he was gone. Lincoln
couldn’t give us much information. He said Neil had rushed up to their
place about dark, looking as if the constable was after him, and offered
to sell that black filly of his to Lincoln for sixty dollars if Lincoln
would drive him to the station in time to catch the excursion train. The
filly was Neil’s own, and Lincoln had been wanting to buy her but Neil
would never hear to it afore. Lincoln jumped at the chance. Neil had
brought the filly with him, and Lincoln hitched right up and took him
to the station. Neil hadn’t no luggage of any kind and wouldn’t open his
mouth the whole way up, Lincoln says. We concluded him and old Thomas
must have had a row. D’ye know anything about it? Or was you so wrapped
up in sweethearting that you didn’t hear or see nothing else?"
Eric reflected rapidly. He was greatly relieved to find that Neil had
gone. He would never return and this was best for all concerned. Old
Robert must be told a part of the truth at least, since it would soon
become known that Kilmeny could speak.
"There was some trouble at the Gordon place to-night, Mr. Williamson,"
he said quietly. "Neil Gordon behaved rather badly and frightened
Kilmeny terribly,—so terribly that a very surprising thing has
happened. She has found herself able to speak, and can speak perfectly."
Old Robert laid down the piece of cheese he was conveying to his mouth
on the point of a knife and stared at Eric in blank amazement.
"God bless my soul, Master, what an extraordinary thing!" he ejaculated.
"Are you in earnest? Or are you trying to see how much of a fool you can
make of the old man?"
"No, Mr. Williamson, I assure you it is no more than the simple truth.
Dr. Baker told me that a shock might cure her,—and it has. As for Neil,
he has gone, no doubt for good, and I think it well that he has."
Not caring to discuss the matter further, Eric left the kitchen. But as
he mounted the stairs to his room he heard old Robert muttering, like a
man in hopeless bewilderment,
"Well, I never heard anything like this in all my born
days—never—never. Timothy, did YOU ever hear the like? Them Gordons
are an unaccountable lot and no mistake. They couldn’t act like other
people if they tried. I must wake mother up and tell her about this, or
I’ll never be able to sleep."
Public-domain original text shown for study context.
What happens here
Chapter 18 — Neil Gordon Solves His Own Problem continues Kilmeny of the Orchard, focusing on music, innocence, romance, silence, beauty, family, and trust. The chapter moves the reader through a specific pressure, choice, or change in the story.
Why this scene matters
This section matters because it shows one part of Kilmeny of the Orchard's larger pattern: music, innocence, romance, silence, beauty, family, and trust. Reading the situation first makes the older prose easier to follow.
Characters in this scene
- Main characters: The people whose choices carry this part of Kilmeny of the Orchard.
- Family or social world: The relationships, class pressures, rules, or expectations shaping the chapter.
- Narrative pressure: The conflict, secret, desire, or consequence that keeps this section moving.